Customers and buying decisions
Decision criteria: meaning and practical examples
Decision criteria are the factors a person uses to judge and compare alternatives. They can include required conditions and preferred qualities, and their importance depends on the task and the customer’s circumstances.
At a glance
- Separate non-negotiable requirements from preferences.
- Compare alternatives using the same meaning and units.
- A weighted score is a decision aid, not objective proof of the best choice.
On this page

What makes a criterion useful?
A criterion should help distinguish options in relation to the task. “Good quality” is too vague unless the reader knows what it means here. For a folding table, relevant criteria might include stability, stored size and whether one person can move it.
OpenStax's positioning discussion considers attributes that matter in customer choices. The useful attributes depend on the offer and audience, not a universal checklist. Product positioning and attributes
Requirement or preference?
A requirement can rule an option out. A preference helps compare options that remain suitable. A table that cannot fit through the door fails a practical condition, even if it has the preferred color and price.
Begin with the customer need. If the task is unclear, a detailed scoring sheet can create precision around the wrong decision.
Example: choosing a neighborhood caterer
Imagine a small team comparing catering for a morning meeting. Delivery before the meeting and an appropriate dietary option are requirements. Presentation, packaging and menu variety may be preferences, depending on the group.
The comparison should use the same number of people and included services for each offer. A per-person price excluding delivery cannot be fairly compared with a complete delivered total without explanation. These are illustrative criteria, not a prescribed purchasing method.
Should criteria receive weights?
Weights can make priorities visible, but assigning numbers does not turn judgment into a measured fact. Explain who selected them and why. A small change in weights can reverse a close result.
In a comparison article, a clear description of tradeoffs may be more useful than a single winner. Show when each option fits and where information is missing.
How do criteria change over time?
A first-time buyer may focus on ease of use; a returning customer may prioritize compatibility with existing equipment. Urgency, experience and operating conditions can change the purchase decision.
Review the criteria against actual questions and current offer details. Avoid selecting only factors that make your own product win. A trustworthy explanation acknowledges relevant weaknesses as well as strengths.